There were times when there riots in Africa, demonstrations against the IMF because of the policy advice they were giving, the conditionalities they were imposing and the difficulties that arose out of the implementation of those conditionalities. – Jakaya Kikwete, former President of Tanzania

I am a child of the 1990s, I grew up in Kenya when the economy was crap, and the politics was hot. Something I used to hear a lot about on the news at the time was the IMF, alongside words like reform, privatization, and taxes.

Today it feels like a bad remake of the film ‘Back to the Future’ because the economy is crap and the politics is hot, and the IMF is driving economic policy. Today Kenya is implementing broad tax increases on fuel, incomes, imports, and businesses and even mulling carbon taxes on the advice of the IMF. Privatization is top of the agenda and ‘reform’ is everywhere, conditions of the IMF program that the country has entered because of fiscal distress. Kenya is not the only country on the continent under an IMF program, Ghana, Zambia, Mozambique, SA etc. are all under IMF ‘guidance’.

In the 1990’s under the structural adjustment programs imposed the IMF, African countries were forced to liberalise their economies, sell off state assets, pull down trade barriers and dismantle social safety nets. Causing immense pain and hardship on the back of policies dictated by disconnected bureaucrats and economists in Washington. Today, African countries are being advised to increase taxes, remove cushioning subsidies and tax breaks, let the value of currencies depreciate and sell off state assets, that are once again causing immense pain.

How did we get back here? How do we get out of it again? Most importantly how do we make sure that it never happens again?

How did we get here?

Getting out of the clutches of the IMF in the first couple of decades of the 2000’s took a lot of hard work, a booming Chinese economy and debt Jubilee from the west. How did we get back here? As with most things it was a combination of stupidity, naivete, and bad luck.

Stupidity: We borrowed too much for projects with disappointing returns (like Kenya’s SGR) or it was outright stolen like the tuna boat scandal in Mozambique. Essentially wasting the money that we had borrowed.

Naivete: After the financial crisis of 2008-09 money in the developed world was cheap, with 0% interest rates. Thus, that money needed by investors, pension funds, banks etc. was looking for returns. African governments seeing cheap money looking for a place to go, floated all manner of Eurobonds, dollar bonds and took syndicated loans and with our aforementioned stupidity, we spent it on the wrong things.

Bad Luck: The Covid-19 pandemic gave every economy a kick in the teeth, stopping growth and investment and then in 2022 the perfect storm hit, inflation forced interest rates up and the cheap money disappeared, at the same time those increased interest rates made the dollar much stronger, thus debt payments had higher interest rates and a dollar penalty. The war in Ukraine caused global food and energy prices to increase steeply, and with most African countries being net fuel and food importers., those imports got more expensive.

How do we get out of it (again)?

In the early 2000s African got lucky on two fronts. The Chinese economy boomed driving demand and prices of the raw materials up and providing a much needed boost for African economies after the IMF induced stagnation of the 1990s. Secondly, many African countries were granted debt relief under the highly indebted poor countries initiative, giving much breathing room to African economies that had been struggling under a significant debt burden. However, the continent cannot rely on lightning striking twice, thus we must actively put in place solutions that get us out of this situation.

Tax reform

First, Africa needs more of its own revenue, which means taxes. However, unlike the IMF’s advice African governments should not be putting additional taxes on their already overburdened citizens who make up their narrow taxbases. As I have written about previously by reforming the tax regimes for natural resources, targeting tax avoidance by multi-nationals, and expanding the tax base, African countries can expand their revenue collection without squeezing their citizens for little gain, with higher income and consumption taxes as many are doing on the advice of the IMF.

Spending Cuts

Second, spending cuts. Governments, particularly African governments waste money on unnecessary or silly things. The most glaring example is Ghana’s national cathedral. Focusing spending on the fundamentals, paying salaries, delivering services and key development projects, while cutting unnecessary spending would give governments some breathing room and ease the crowding out effect in domestic debt markets that is seeing governments borrow every cent they can, leaving little for the private sector to borrow, limiting investment and growth.

The IMF

Third, use the IMF. Not the institution, but its assets through something called Strategic Drawing Rights (SDR) these are interest bearing international reserve assets of member countries of the member countries of the IMF. SDRs are allocated to IMF members in proportion to their quotas of shares. SDR’s are held by states or specified institutions such as the Africa Development Bank (AfDB) as part of their forex reserves or they can be used to pay the IMF for loans or transactions. Many wealthy countries are holding SDRs that they do not use, and in the past the G20 pledged to reallocate $100 billion worth of SDRs to Africa. The Africa Development Bank has calculated that with its AAA credit rating it could leverage the funds as much as 4 times, meaning $100 billion could deliver $400 billion to African economies. Part of that could be used to help African countries refinance and restructure, dollar-based debts.

For instance, Kenya has $2 billion dollar bond payment it must pay in 2024. If it defaults, it would be disastrous to its economy and currency. If it tried to finance the payment through its own revenues it would cripple the government requiring massive cuts to services and personnel. If it tried to refinance the bond through international markets the interest would punish the country for years to come. If through the AfDB Kenya was able to refinance the bond, at favourable rates, for a period of time that made sense, Kenya bond holders would be paid back, and the country would get the economic and fiscal breathing space it needs to invest in development and not tax its private sector and citizens to desperation. This wouldn’t be a bailout or debt Jubilee, in the end Kenya would pay the money back to AfDB. There is no need for the painful choices Kenya and many other African states are being forced into, when the AfDB could use already pledged assets to solve the problem.

How do we make sure it never happens again?

Assuming we can find our way out of this mess, how do we make sure that Africa never loses its economic sovereignty to the IMF or other non-African institutions again. It won’t be easy, and it won’t be simple, but it is worth doing.

Discipline. African countries need to develop fiscal discipline, the days of presidents and political leaders using treasuries as personal playthings must end. If not the vanity projects, white elephants and waste will continue to drive bad debts and IMF bailouts.

African Capital Markets. As the continent comes closer together around trade, climate issues, and payment systems, we should add capital markets to that list. Why go to Europe or America to float sovereign bonds or raise capital, why not do it in Africa. Raising money from markets and investors that better understand and appreciate Africa. Most African markets rely on a combination of domestic markets, draining capital away from the private sector, and unreasonably expensive Eurobonds and syndicated bank loans. Developing regional/pan-African capital market would open a new venue for African countries to borrow potentially in their own currencies.

Expertise. Many of the African finance ministries who “took advantage” of international capital markets over the last two-decades, have, unfortunately shown that they do not fully grasp the complexity and repercussions of these markets. Thankfully long-gone are the days where there are not enough Africans with the right type of skills. There are more than enough qualified African bankers, financial experts and advisors who have worked from wall street to Hong-Kong executing complex transactions and trading in these markets. It is time to bring this expertise in house. Debt departments at ministries of finance need these people staffing them to develop viable debt strategies that are built for long term sustainability.

Conclusion – Back to future

In the film back to the future the protagonist, who went back in time eventually goes back to the future, safe, sound and more secure than before. We must strive for the same for the future of the continent’s fiscal well-being. A prosperous future for Africa, requires Africans being in-charge of our fiscal resources not faceless bureaucrats from the other side of the world. Questions around how African countries tax their citizens, where they spend that tax revenue and what they should be borrowing for should be debated and determined at home not in Washington, Brussels, or Beijing.

Africa is back in the IMF debt trap, and just like in the 1990s African countries are sacrificing their citizens through higher taxes, cutting services, and selling assets as demanded by the IMF in the name of sound economic reform. Getting out of this debt trap will be harder and likely more painful than the last time, but if we don’t our sovereignty will continue to be second class.